
View from Chip Yates' electric bike.
Focused on the design of energy efficient products and processes
Pragmatic commentary on developments in energy efficiency and society's use and mis-use of energy sources.
Lee Teschler
Lee Teschler, executive editor of EE&T, has been writing and editing technical ...
View More

View from Chip Yates' electric bike.
There was an interesting item in the latest issue of North American Windpower, the official organ of the American Wind Energy Association. In an article on midsized turbines — those with rated capacities of 100 kW to 1 MW — there are two notable points. One is that turbines in the 100 kW to 500 kW range have been expensive on a dollars-per-kilowatt basis. Later on, it notes that the majority of turbines in the 600 kW to 1.5 MW range are manufactured overseas.
No such observation about the origins of smaller wind turbines. But we might make the observation that you may have here machines coming from overseas sources that are perceived as expensive. The lesson, if there is one, should be that overseas sourcing won’t overcome basic economic problems of a design paradigm. Our view is that the wind industry really needs a different approach than conventional horizontal wind turbines if it ever hopes to generate power economically without the benefit of subsidies. Candidates would include vertical wind turbine designs and horizontal machines that use fluid power rather than conventional gearboxes in the nacelle.
You can find out a bit more about hydraulic wind turbines here: http://machinedesign.com/article/hydraulic-wind-turbines-0420